|
|
Bodh Gaya is a large village situated at latitude 24° 41' 45"
N, longitude 85° 2' 2" E, in the southern part of the Indian
state of Bihar. The environment around the village is rural, being
made up of cultivated areas interspersed with open ground on which
grow mango, tamarind and palm trees [ 1. VIEW
IMAGE ]. Beside the village flows the wide but shallow
Lilanjan River. In Buddhist scriptures, this river is called Neranjara,
a name derived from the words pleasant (nelam) or alternatively
blue (nila), and water (jalam). About a mile downstream from Bodh
Gaya, the Lilanjan joins the Mohana to form the Phalgu River which
flows past Gaya and is considered sacred to the Hindus.
The name Bodh Gaya has been spelt variously as Boodha Gaya, Buddh
Gya, Bauddha Gyah, Bodhi Gaya, and Buddha Gaya. In any of its forms,
it is not an old name, first occurring in the spurious inscription
of Amaradeva, a document of uncertain but recent date. At the time
of the Buddha, the village was named Uruvela. According to 5th century
commentator Dharmapala, it was given this name because of the large
amount of sand (vela) in the area. He tells a delightful story to
explain the presence of all this sand. In the distant past, long
before the Buddha, a company of ascetics lived in the area. They
could tell which one of their fellows committed an unwholesome bodily
or verbal act, but not if they had an unwholesome thought. So they
came to an agreement among themselves, that whoever thinks an unwholesome
thought should bring sand in a leaf basket. Soon the whole area
was covered with sand.
Other sources say the village was given the name on account of
a vilva tree (Aegie marmelas) growing nearby. It seems that within
two centuries of the Buddha's enlightenment, the name Uruvela fell
into disuse and was replaced by four other names: Sambodhi, Bodhimanda,
Vajrasana and Mahabodhi. The oldest and least commonly used of these
names was Sambodhi, meaning 'complete enlightenment'. In his Eighth
Rock Edict issued in 256 BC, King Asoka says he "went to Sambodhi"
(ayaya Sambodhi) referring to his pilgrimage to Bodh Gaya four years
previously [ 2. VIEW
IMAGE ]. Another ancient name, Bodhimanda, refers to
a circular area around the Bodhi Tree. The Kalingabodhi Jataka describes
the Bodhimanda before the Buddha's enlightenment as being covered
with silvery sand without a blade of grass growing on it and with
all the surrounding trees and flowering shrubs bending, as if in
homage, towards the Bodhi Tree.
The exact place where the Buddha sat when he was enlightened was
called Vajrasana meaning 'Diamond Throne'. It was believed that
when the universe is finally destroyed, this would be the last place
to disappear and that it would be the first place to form when the
universe began to re-evolve again. The Vajrasana was also sometimes
called The Victory Throne of all Buddhas (Sabbabuddhanam Jayapallankam)
or the Navel of the Earth (Pathavinabhi). In later centuries the
name Vajrasana came to be used for the exact location of the Buddha's
enlightenment, for the temple built over it (Vajrasana Gandhakuti)
and for the general location.
The most widely used and also the most enduring of Bodh Gaya's
names was Mahabodhi meaning 'great enlightenment'. Originally a
term for the Buddha's experience, it later came to be used as the
name for the place where that experience had occurred. Cunningham
mentioned that this name was still in vogue in the 19th century.
The Buddha's experience at Uruvela not only resulted in the location
changing its name to Bodh Gaya; it has also meant that this otherwise
obscure village has been the focus of attention for millions of
pilgrims for over two millennia. It became very early, and remains
even today, the most important place of Buddhist pilgrimage. Those
who see Buddhism as an entirely rational religion will insist that
it has no place for practices like pilgrimage. However, this view
is somewhat at odds with what the Buddha himself said. Just before
his final Nirvana, he encouraged all his disciples to visit at least
once the places where the pivotal events in his life occurred: Lumbini,
Bodh Gaya, Isipatana and Kusinara:
"Ananda, there are four places the sight
of which will arouse strong emotion in those with faith. Which
four? 'Here the Tathagata was born', this is the first place.
'Here the Tathagata attained Enlightenment', this is the second
place. 'Here the Tathagata set in motion the Wheel of the Dhamma',
this is the third place. 'Here the Tathagata attained final Nirvana
without remainder', this is the fourth place. The monk or nun,
layman or laywoman, who has faith should visit these places. And
anyone who dies while making a pilgrimage to these places with
a devout heart will, at the breaking up of the body, be reborn
in heaven".
While it is true that the Buddha had high regard for reason, he
did at the same time recognise the importance of emotion in all
human endeavours, including the quest for enlightenment. For the
devout person, seeing the Buddha or even thinking about him can
evoke a joy which, when controlled and purified, can be transformational.
Going to a place made sacred by the Buddha's presence, or even the
process of getting there, can have a similar effect. On the open
road, away from mundane preoccupations and familiar surroundings,
the pilgrim has time to think about his or her life and practice
of the Dhamma. The arduous but steady progress towards the goal
may become analogous to the pilgrim's journey on the Eightfold Path
and stimulate the determination to walk that Path with more commitment.
On finally reaching the goal, the pilgrim will see places and sights
associated with the Buddha which can arouse intense faith and provide
the opportunity for deep contemplation.
In ancient times, there were several approaches to Bodh Gaya. Pilgrims
coming from the west could go overland from Benares, taking the
same road that the Buddha took in the first year after his enlightenment.
The other way was to sail further down the Ganges to Pataliputra
and then take the road south to Gaya, or alternatively, the slightly
longer road that passed through Nalanda, Rajagaha and Kurkihar.
Pilgrims from Bengal or Orissa would sail up the Ganges or take
the road that linked Magadha to Tamralipti. These approaches were
an integral part of the great road system that connected the towns
and cities of the Ganges valley.
There were three main routes in this system - the northern which
paralleled the Himalayan foothills and connected Ahicchatra, Sravasti
and Saketa to Benares; the central which followed the Ganges and
passed through Hastinapura, Sankasya and Kanyakubja to Prayaga;
and the southern which followed the Yamuna, passed Kausambi and
joined the central route at Prayaga. A branch of the northern route
went from Sravasti, through Kapilavatthu, Kusinara and Vesali to
Pataliputra. Pilgrims from Kashmir, Bactria and beyond followed
the great trunk road that started at Taksila and ran to Hastinapura
where it joined the northern route. Few records of pilgrims from
these regions have survived.
A monk named Viradeva from Bactria is known to have visited Bodh
Gaya twice, once as a young man, and again many years later when
he was appointed head of the great monastery at Nalanda. I Tsing
mentions a monk from Samarkand who came to Bodh Gaya, where he burned
lamps for seven days and set up statues of the Buddha and Avalokitesvara
at the foot of the Bodhi Tree. Sindh was a predominantly Buddhist
region until the Arab invasion in the 8th century. The earliest
record of pilgrims from this region coming to Bodh Gaya is an inscription
thought to date from the reign of King Gopala II (950 -970).
From Sindh there were three ways to the Ganges valley, one starting
at Roruka and another at Sibipura, which both converged at Sairisaka
from where it ran to Indraprastha and Mathura. Another possibility
was to go from Patala to Gujarat, and then take the main road to
the north through Ujjayini and Vidisa. The southern end of this
road passed Nasikya and Ajanta, and was the main route for pilgrims
coming from Deccan and the cities on the northwestern seaboard.
Pilgrims from the Tamil country and Andhra could go either by foot
or ship up the east coast to Tamralipti. No evidence of visits by
South Indian Buddhists have yet been found at Bodh Gaya, but pilgrims
from Kerala and particularly from Kanchipuram are known to have
visited Kurkihar in large numbers during the 10th and 11th centuries.
It is inconceivable that they did not go the extra 16 miles to Bodh
Gaya.
Pilgrims from beyond India travelled on the international trade
routes. Sri Lankans embarked from either Mahatittha or Jambukola
and sailed up the coast to Tamralipti, sometimes stopping at Kanchipuram
or Amaravati on the way. Going directly with a favourable breeze,
the pilgrim could be in Tamralipti in as little as 14 days. The
Rasavahini's mention of a four month journey from 'the further shore'
(i.e. the Indian coast opposite Sri Lanka) to Bodh Gaya must have
applied to those who made the whole journey on foot. Pilgrims from
Sumatra and Java usually arrived at Tamralipti via South Indian
ports, taking advantage of the large number of ships that sailed
between the two regions.
During the 11th century, Acarya Dharmakirti of Sumatra, probably
the greatest Buddhist scholar Southeast Asia ever produced, made
a pilgrimage to Bodh Gaya, Lumbini and Kapilavatthu, although it
is not known what route he took to India. Ships from Burma avoided
the open sea because of the sudden storms in the Bay of Bengal,
but as a consequence were often a prey to the notorious Malay pirates
that infested the Araccan coast. Amongst the numerous graffiti that
pilgrims scratched on the rocks at Uren, the probable abode of Avalaka,
are some in Burmese script. Pilgrims from Burma sailing up the Ganges
to Bodh Gaya via Pataliputra must have broken their journey there
to visit Uren's shrines. It was also possible for Burmese to go
overland through Assam, but few seemed to use this particularly
dangerous route.
According to the famous Kalyani inscription, a 13th century Burmese
monk took advantage of the psychic powers he had developed in meditation
to fly to Bodh Gaya each day and sweep the temple courtyard. While
this story may not be true, it does reflect the intense desire that
many Burmese had to visit the site of the Buddha's enlightenment.
Chinese and Korean pilgrims had two choices, to go by ship through
Southeast Asia or overland through the mountains and deserts of
Central Asia. This second route in particular posed numerous difficulties,
some of which the monk Sung Yun described:
"Along the road, the cold was very severe
while the winds, driving snow and the pelting sand and grit were
so bad that it was impossible to raise one's eyes without getting
them filled".
A few Chinese pilgrims went by a third route, through Tibet and
Nepal, a journey that was still a formidable undertaking well into
the 20th century. The Korean monk Yuan Tai went this way to Bodh
Gaya. On his return journey through Central Asia, he met another
monk going to Bodh Gaya and decided to accompany him. After this
second visit, he managed to return safely to his homeland. The only
Japanese known to have attempted a pilgrimage to India in ancient
times was Prince Takaoka, who had been an heir to the throne before
becoming a monk. In 866 AD, at the age of 70, he set sail from Canton
but was never heard of again. He is thought to have died somewhere
in the Malay Peninsula before having reached his goal.
Vietnamese began going to India on pilgrimage soon after the introduction
of Buddhism into their country in the 6th century. One of the earliest
such records concerns two monks, Khuy-Sung Phap Su and Minh Vien,
who took a ship to Sri Lanka, sailed up the west coast of India
and then went from there by foot to the holy land. The two companions
reached Bodh Gaya and then continued on to Rajagaha where poor Khuy-Sung
died. He was only twenty five years old. According to Shes-bya-kun-khyab
the first Tibetan to go to Bodh Gaya was Akaramatisila who was sent
to India by Srong-btsan-sgam-po to get a statue of Avalokitesvara.
On the way back he stopped in Bodh Gaya to get leaves from the Bodhi
tree and sand from the Naranjara River. The earliest evidence of
pilgrims from Nepal coming to Bodh Gaya is a number of coins
[ 3. VIEW IMAGE ] dating from
the reign of the Nepalese King Pasupati (approximately 400 AD).
Most pilgrims travelled on foot or by bullock cart, except where
it was possible to ply the Ganges or the Yamuna. Monks slung their
bowl and water pot over their shoulder and carried either an umbrella
or staff. The Vinaya says that a staff should be four times the
length from the fingertips to the elbow of a man of average height.
In later times, the staff, called a khakharaka because of the jingling
sound made by the metal rings on its top, became a symbol of wayfaring
and pilgrimage, much as the bourdon did in medieval Christendom
[ 4. VIEW IMAGE ]. The pilgrim
could use it to ward off unfriendly dogs or wild animals, and give
notice of his presence when he went begging for alms. Ksitigarbha,
the bodhisattva who protects travellers, is always depicted holding
such a staff.
Senior monks from more wealthy monasteries travelled by palanquin,
accompanied by an attendant with their belongings. The travelling
kit of Sri Lankan monks on pilgrimage within their own country would
consist of a water strainer, needle and thread, a small jar of oil
for massaging the feet, nail clipper, tinder and flint, and a pair
of sandals with a case to put them in. Those who went to India must
have been similarly outfitted. Local guilds, philanthropists and
kings sometimes built simple rest-houses along main roads which
offered shelter, although little more, for pilgrims and traders.
The Manjusrimulakalpa eulogised the 8th century King Gopala as
"a maker of beautiful rest-houses and bridges". There
were no inns in ancient India; centres of pilgrimages had dharmasalas,
but beyond that, travellers arriving at a town and needing accommodation
had to go from door to door looking for someone who might take them
in. It was a little easier for monks. Wayside temples would take
in travelling monks for three, or in some places five, days, after
which they would have to move on. But temples were not always hospitable,
particularly if the monk seeking accommodation was from a rival
sect or a foreign country.
Hsuan Tsang visited a monastery cast of Benares named Aviddhakarna
Vihara (Monastery of the Unpierced Ears) and was told an interesting
story of why it was built and how it got its name. A group of monks
from beyond India's northwestern frontier were on pilgrimage but
could find no monastery that would take them in. One day, the king
happened to see them in the street and, recognising that they were
not Indians by the fact that their ears were unpierced, asked them
why they were so ragged and thin. When they told him, he decided
to build a monastery for the exclusive use of foreign monks. Indians,
that is those with pierced ears, were not allowed to stay there
and hence the monastery's name.
There are known to have been several other monasteries for foreign
monks travelling or studying in India, one at Bodh Gaya for Sri
Lankans, one at Nalanda for Javanese and Sumatrans [
5. VIEW IMAGE ], and another
east of Nalanda for Chinese. This 'Cheena Vihara' had been built
by King Sri Gupta and allotted 24 villages for its upkeep. But even
when monasteries were unavailable, lay people were usually happy
to help travelling monks. In the Sihalavatthupakarana there is a
story of seven Sri Lankan monks who arrived at Pataliputra on their
way to Bodh Gaya. The daughter of a rich merchant saw them in the
street and invited them into her home for a meal. On being told
they were on their way to Bodh Gaya, she gave them golden flowers,
incense and lamps to offer at the Bodhi Tree on her behalf. She
also provided them with servants and a bullock cart for the final
stage of their journey.
For safety's sake, pilgrims usually travelled in groups or teamed
up with caravans that plied the main trade routes. The monk Nagasena
travelled from northwest India to Pataliputra with a caravan of
500 wagons. The caravan leader supplied all his food and, when they
finally parted, gave him a beautiful woolen blanket. In about the
middle of the 11th century, the envoy sent to invite Atisa to Tibet
travelled to Bodh Gaya with the king of Nepal and his entourage
before completing his mission. Another Tibetan, Dharmasvamin, and
16 other pilgrims on their way to Bodh Gaya in 1234, travelled through
northern Bihar with a party of 300 Nepalese Hindus taking their
deceased parents' ashes to immerse in the Ganges.
When Hiuen Tsiang was in Kanchipuram in the 7th century some 300
Sri Lankan monks arrived in the city. It seems they had found it
judicious to come to India on pilgrimage at that particular time
due to political upheavals in the island following the death of
the king. Later Hiuen Tsiang travelled through the Tamil country
with 70 of these monks; apparently they were going to north India.
To help pay their way, many pilgrims would buy goods in one destination
to sell them in another. Visaka of Pataliputra sewed coins into
the hem of his garment before setting out on his journey. He used
the month he was kept waiting for a ship to do some business and
managed to make a handsome profit.
A Tibetan monk earned 12 gold zos, enough money to finance his
pilgrimage to India, by copying out two sets of the Satasahasrikaprajnaparamita
Sutra. Some incurred expenses even before they set out. Hindus from
Kashmir going to Gaya had to pay a special pilgrim's tax, and we
can assume it must have been the same for Kashmiri Buddhists going
to Bodh Gaya. For Chinese pilgrims it was not taxes but the formidable
imperial bureaucracy that posed the greatest obstacle. Before leaving
the country they had to apply for and obtain a passport.
The popularity of pilgrimage gave rise to a whole body of literature,
mainly sutras praising the holy places and exhorting the faithful
to visit them. Sri Lankan monks had small handbooks (muttipotthaka)
listing the Buddha's virtues which they could read while they travelled.
There were also guide books (mahatyaya) to help pilgrims to find
their way, and inform them of the times of particular festivals
that were held at each sacred place. Some of the early biographies
of the Buddha, like the Lalitavistara, are thought to have been
based upon such guide books which in turn grew out of the patter
that guides at the various holy places used. Although no guide books
have survived, several such works are known. The only one of these
about which we have any details is the guidebook to Bodh Gaya written
by Jamdun Rigpel Rilti in the 14th century.
Ancient Buddhist maps always showed either Mount Meru or Bodh Gaya
in their centre. The most famous of these is the Gotenjiku Zu, Map
of the Five Indias, drawn by the Japanese monk Juaki in 1364. This
map is based carefully on Hiuan Tsiang's account of his pilgrimage
to India and indeed even marks his route with a red line. Mount
Meru and Lake Anotatta with the traditional four rivers flowing
out of it is shown in the centre while Bodh Gaya is located towards
the southeast. The purpose of maps like the Gotenjiku Zu was didactic
and scholarly rather than practical. This is clear from Juaki's
own words. He says; "With prayers in my heart that Buddhism
might prosper, I engaged myself in the task of making this copy,
wiping my eyes which are dim with age, and feeling that I myself
were actually travelling through India". However route maps
meant to be used by those going to India did exist too. These were
probably not available for ordinary pilgrims but were made by and
for royal embassies visiting India. One of the few such maps that
survives, from northern Thailand, was drawn in the 19th century
although based on a much earlier prototype, probably by someone
who had actually been to India. The map shows important pilgrimage
sites like Rajagaha, Kusinara, Campa and Dona's stupa, and gives
their direction and the number of days needed to reach them from
the Mahabodhi Temple, which is depicted in the centre of the map
[ 6. VIEW IMAGE
].
In order to facilitate both trade and pilgrimage, King Asoka had
main roads lined with trees, and wells dug at regular intervals
along them. He also had the road from Bodh Gaya to his capital at
Pataliputra straightened and repaired. However, throughout most
of India's history, roads were appallingly bad and travel for any
reason was difficult and dangerous. The remains of two finely built
roads that ascend the hill at Sanchi show the capabilities of ancient
Indian engineers. But these roads were probably only for royal processions;
pilgrims had to scramble up the hill as best they could. At Chikni
Ghati on the northeastern side of the hill, the feet of generations
of pilgrims have worn the rocks smooth. Bridges were rare, and rivers
usually had to be forded or crossed by ferry. According to the Lalitavistara,
a ferryman refused to take the Buddha across a river because he
had no money to pay the fee, a story that must have mirrored the
experience of many a wayfaring monk and poor pilgrim.
A 13th century Tibetan pilgrim mentions crossing the Ganges on
a craft that consisted of two square rafts lashed together. The
river was full of crocodiles that would sometimes try to upset craft
or snatch passengers off their decks. In some areas the distances
between one town and the next were considerable, and pilgrims were
in danger of getting lost or running out of provisions. In the Anguttara
Nikaya we read of the traveller's relief on coming upon a pond where
he could drink (and perhaps swim, eat some lotus roots and rest
in the shade) before moving on refreshed. Others might have to get
down on all fours and drink from a wayside puddle because no other
water was available. Less lucky pilgrims perished from hunger and
thirst. Sickness was always a threat, especially for those not used
to India's dust, heat, and poor food and water.
The Korean pilgrim Hsuan-Ko made it all the way to Bodh Gaya only
to die of sickness a few days after his arrival. One of Fa Hien's
companions died of altitude sickness while crossing the Hindu Kush.
But the the perennial problem of travel in India was banditry. Nearly
every traveller in the subcontinent up to the last century mentions
this danger. The boat that Hsuan Tsang took down river to Prayaga
was attacked by river pirates who dragged it to the shore, robbed
the passengers, and then decided that the Chinese pilgrim with his
fair skin would be a suitable sacrifice for their goddess Kali.
It was only by a stroke of luck that he escaped with his life.
After returning from Tibet in 1426, the Indian Tantric adept Vanaratna
planned to go to Bodh Gaya to pay his respects and erect a statue
of his teacher. But upon learning that bandits were laying in wait
to steal the Tibetan king's gifts that he was carrying, he had to
cancel his trip. Some poor pilgrims had to endure all these difficulties
and more. In the account of his third journey to India, during which
he went to Bodh Gaya, a peeved Marpa complained that he encountered
bandits, wild animals and suffered greatly from fever and the searing
heat of the Indian plains.
The vicissitudes faced by the Chinese pilgrim I Tsing, during his
journey to Bodh Gaya in the 7th century, were perhaps typical of
many. Before leaving China, I Tsing met with the captain of the
Persian ship he was travelling on, visited his teacher's grave and
said farewell to his family and friends. Embarking at Canton in
671 AD, the ship took 20 days to reach Bogha (probably Jambhi in
Sumatra) where he stayed for 2 months learning Sanskrit in preparation
for his arrival in India. After a further 2 months' stay in Kedha,
he set sail again. Ten days out, the ship stopped at the Andaman
Islands, where water and provisions were exchanged with the natives
for iron. Another half a month sailing across the Andaman Sea and
I Tsing's ship finally arrived at Tamralipti. There, to his delight
and surprise, he met a monk from his homeland. After a few more
months' study at one of Tamralipti's monasteries, the two men joined
up with a party of several hundred merchants and monks heading for
Magadha. Ten days journey from Bodh Gaya, the party passed through
a wilderness and I Tsing, being sick, fell behind. Around sunset,
a group of men approached the lone pilgrim and began insulting him
and threatening him with their weapons. Finding that he had nothing
of value to steal, they stripped him of his clothes, obliging him
to cover himself with a handful of leaves. Staggering on through
the darkness, he finally arrived at the next village where he was
able to rejoin his companions. Twenty monks in the party were going
directly to Nalanda and, not wishing to travel alone, I Tsing decided
to accompany them and proceed to Bodh Gaya from there. On finally
arriving at his goal, he offered the silk and canopies that had
been given to him for the purpose by friends in China to the Mahabodhi
image, and prayed for the peace and prosperity of his homeland.
Later I Tsing visited all the other sacred places and then spent
10 years studying at Nalanda, before finally returning to China
in 695 AD. Despite these and other difficulties, pilgrimage remained
an important and popular religious practice for centuries. During
Buddhism's heyday in India, millions of people from both within
the subcontinent and beyond its borders travelled to Bodh Gaya and
other sacred places. This great movement of people had a significant
impact on Indian culture. Going to any place of Buddhist pilgrimage
required passing at least several others, which helped widely separated
monastic communities to keep in contact with each other. It also
facilitated the spread of new ideas while allowing Indian Buddhism
to retain a unified character. Foreign pilgrims brought news of
the conditions of Buddhism in far off places and stimulated Indian
monks to travel abroad. They also carried back to their homelands
relics, books, statues and even plans of Indian temples, all of
which had an impact on the art and thought in other parts of Asia.
Foreign pilgrims occasionally kept in contact with Indians they
had met during their travels, sometimes for many years. The most
remarkable example of such long-distance relationships are the letters
that passed between the Chinese monk Hsuan Tsang and two monks from
Bodh Gaya, Prajnadeva and Jnanaprabha. Seven years after his return
to China in 641, Hsuan Tsang received letters and several rolls
of cotton cloth from these monks [ 7. VIEW
IMAGE ]. In their letters, they wished Hsuan Tsang well,
passed on the regards of a mutual friend and offered to send him
any books he might need for his studies. Two years later, when a
Chinese monk was setting out for India, Hsuan Tsang gave him two
letters to be delivered at Bodh Gaya. In his reply to Prajnadeva,
Hsuan Tsang expressed his delight in hearing from his friend after
so long, talked about the weather and his work, and also gave a
list of books he wanted sent. The fact that letters, gifts and books
could be passed from one individual to another over such vast distances
indicates that pilgrim traffic to and from Bodh Gaya must have been
very considerable.
The dangers and expense involved in going to India on pilgrimage
meant that only a very small number of devotees were able to do
it. Most had to be content with visiting the centres of pilgrimage
that grew up in their own lands, and this trend was extenuated after
the Muslim conquest of India. This diversion of people away from
Bodh Gaya was a factor in its gradual decline, and also in its inability
to recover from the blows inflicted on it in the 13th century. However,
although the stream of Buddhists to Bodh Gaya declined dramatically,
it never stopped completely. A trickle of pilgrims, mainly from
Tibet, Nepal and Burma, continued right up to the 19th century.
But it was not until the Mahabodhi Society started organising pilgrimages
in the 1890's that significant numbers of people began coming again
[ 8. VIEW IMAGE
]. Going to Bodh Gaya is once more a part of Buddhist practice
and perhaps more pilgrims make the journey today than ever before
in history [ 9. VIEW
IMAGE ].
|
|
|